Man Sues Tustin California Police – Alleges Assault and Battery – Negligence and False Arrest

Tustin, California –

A 20-year-old man is suing the city, Tustin police and one of its veteran officers, alleging that the officer “physically assaulted and tackled him” for no reason, leaving him with injuries to his face and an arrest record.

In the lawsuit, filed July 31 in Orange County Superior Court, Jose Francisco Franco of Tustin alleges assault and battery, negligence and false arrest. He also alleges three civil rights violations including unlawful seizure of person, excessive force and unconstitutional city policies.

“He had a clear record. He’s a nice, clean-cut kid,” said John Cogorno, an attorney representing Franco in the case. “The officer overreacted under the circumstances. And as a result, the kid was seriously damaged.”

The city, police department and Officer Rene Barraza, who was named in the lawsuit, did not comment on the case. The city hadn’t been served with the suit as of Tuesday, city attorney David Kendig said.

Barraza has been with the Tustin Police Department since 2007, according to an announcement when he won officer of the month in 2013. He’s currently a K-9 officer, and he and his dog, Bravo, are a common sight at community events like Tuesday’s National Night Out.

The incident happened around 11 p.m. June 2, 2014. Franco – who was 19 at the time – was by himself, sitting on the steps outside a medical building on Newport Avenue, listening to music on his cellphone, Cogorno said.

“He just wanted to get out of the house,” Cogorno said.

When Franco saw a police officer drive by, Cogorno said he got up and started walking. It wasn’t because he’d done anything wrong, Cogorno said. It was simply the knee-jerk reaction many people have to avoid the police, he said.

Officer Barraza then approached Franco from behind and tackled him, causing Franco to fall face-first into the sidewalk, the lawsuit alleges.

Franco’s two upper front teeth went through his lip, Cogorno said. His tooth was chipped, and he suffered bruising and swelling to the rest of his face.

Barraza arrested Franco at the scene, the lawsuit states. Paramedics took Franco to a hospital in Santa Ana to treat his injuries, then he was booked into county jail for a misdemeanor charge of willfully delaying, resisting or obstructing an officer.

Franco was ordered to appear in court July 1, 2014, according to the lawsuit. He did, and no charges were filed against him.

He filed a claim with the city in November. The City Council denied the claim in February, so Franco filed the lawsuit.

Franco is suing to cover his medical bills and loss of wages, plus he’s seeking compensation for mental distress and punitive damages.

He was working for a car wash at the time of the incident and had to take 30 days off work to recover from his injuries, Cogorno said. He lost his job during that time, Cogorno said, but found another and is employed now.

Franco’s teeth are still a bit loose and he has a scar on his lip, Cogorno said. But the most upsetting part, Cogorno said, is that Franco now has an arrest record that can potentially impact his chance at jobs, loans or housing.

Contact the writer: 714-796-7963 or

Dock Tax Campaign Reorganizes to Change Newport Beach California City Government

Dear Friend,

Residents for Reform was started for a simple reason – our local government has become too expensive.

Over the past decade we have sat back while well-intentioned politicians have encumbered 87,000 residents with almost $500 million in long-term debt

The city’s budget documents show in 2003 total revenues from all sources was $110 million. This year it’s $254 million, a 131% increase.

Just because Newport Beach is a wealthy community doesn’t mean city government has to gouge, overcharge, and over-tax.

We believe our city is profiting off taxpayers, hence its surplus of $140 million – larger than the entire budget of Costa Mesa.

Residents have been quiet for too long. It’s time for a change.

Bob McCaffrey
Volunteer Chairman

Newport Beach Dock Owners Association Settles Lawsuit Against City of Newport Beach California.

Newport Beach Dock Owners Association Settles Lawsuit Against City of Newport Beach California.

Today the 1,000 residential dock owners of Newport Harbor, represented by the Newport Beach Dock Owners Association, announced it has settled its lawsuit filed in February 2013 against the City of Newport Beach for violating the Ralph M. Brown Act.

“It is unfortunate that we had to sue our own city to restore the equity in our docks that they stole in passing the Dock Tax. The Dock Tax was an unnecessary money grab that while distasteful, paled in comparison to the city stripping us of the property right to our residential pier,” declared Bob McCaffrey, volunteer chairman of the Newport Beach Dock Owners Association & Stop the Dock Tax. This property right is estimated at $1 million in some cases.

The settlement (you can read it here) was executed last week by McCaffrey. We agreed to not initiate discovery, including depositions of councilmembers and key staff in return for;

The 1-year permit has been replaced with a 10 year permit that renews for an additional 10 years.
Upon sale or transfer of the upland homeowner, the pier permit must transfer to the new owner. 50 year total term, similar to the leases in Beacon Bay.
“Anytime government takes a million dollars in our value we will fight, sue, and make changes at city hall,” declared McCaffrey.

McCaffrey concluded, “Stop the Dock Tax PAC will wind up its affairs shortly. The Newport Beach Dock Owners Association will remain active. We will make an announcement in the next few weeks about our plans to make sure tax paying residents are never again forced to sue our city to protect our property from an overbearing government.”